Narta CEO Michael Jackson has said JB Hi-Fi Group’s decision to end its membership will reduce the buying and services organisation’s scale and income, requiring structural and cost changes, while leaving Narta as the third-largest buying group by collective scale.
It was Jackson’s first public comments since the announcement that JB Hi-Fi Group would leave Narta. He said the decision was mutually agreed after discussions with JB’s Nick Wells, and that no event, incident or disagreement caused the exit. JB was not asked to leave, he added.
Scale and strategy
Jackson said Narta without JB still has a strong business, with “core supplier” purchases well above $1 billion and a collective share of more than 20% of the consumer electronics, camera and home appliance market. For suppliers, he argued, that remains significant value.
He stressed that Narta’s role extends beyond buying. It brings independent retailers together to create efficiencies, reduce administration, lower costs and minimise the investment individual businesses must make. Narta is 61 years old and was founded to serve independent retailers, with collective strength and scale intended to help them compete with major retailers.
JB joined Narta more than 25 years ago with a store in Melbourne and a store in Parramatta, Jackson said. He noted that nobody could have predicted its growth into a publicly listed company, and that Narta was proud to have been part of that journey.
Good Guys acquisition changed balance
The acquisition of The Good Guys and its later inclusion in Narta brought considerable scale but also a significant imbalance across the membership, according to Jackson. COVID-19 then arrived soon afterwards, and years of extraordinary industry growth overshadowed many of those underlying changes, he said.
He said the market is now very different. Over the past six months in particular, Narta has recognised a greater responsibility to its shareholders and total membership.
Narta’s services now include forecasting, stock-on-hand visibility, end-of-life management, new model implementation, product content and training, predictive analytics, artificial intelligence and automation. Jackson said independent members need those capabilities to survive and thrive against JB Hi-Fi, Harvey Norman, Bunnings, Woolworths, Big W, Costco and Amazon, and must work collectively to access the required services, technology and investment.
Suppliers and members
Jackson said JB agreed during the discussions that Narta had taken the right path over the past five to six years by investing in and building its service infrastructure. Without those investments, he said, there was every chance Narta would have struggled to fulfil its responsibilities to members.
With JB leaving, he argued it is time for members to embrace that investment, work together, engage fully with the services and deliver value as a collective. Suppliers need a strong independent channel and will challenge it if it cannot demonstrate efficiencies and a competitive cost to serve, he said. Narta expects to be judged by its collective actions over the next 12 months.
He added that suppliers’ cost to serve continues to rise, with the economy, operating costs and market conditions affecting them as much as retailers. JB, by contrast, is a publicly listed company with four businesses — JB Hi-Fi Australia, JB Hi-Fi New Zealand, The Good Guys and e&s — and its own strategic priorities.
Jackson said a few weeks ago the two organisations mutually agreed that Narta should focus on its strategy and members, while JB should focus on its own strategy and priorities. He said there was never going to be a perfect time to end the membership.
Cost base and next steps
Narta will no longer be the largest buying group but will remain number three collectively, Jackson said, describing that as a significant market position that carries value for suppliers and independent retailers.
The loss of JB’s scale is significant and will affect Narta’s income and operating costs. As a not-for-profit organisation whose members contribute to running costs, Narta will need changes to its structure and cost base, he said. Difficult decisions will include redundancies and cost reductions across the board and executive structure.
Jackson said the priority is to keep the organisation financially sustainable, retain the experience and capabilities needed to deliver for members and suppliers, and structure Narta appropriately for the future. Its purpose has not changed, he said: to strengthen independent retail. He believes the need for a strong, connected and commercially effective independent channel is now greater than ever.
